May 1st, 2012 by Brian Beeler
Buying an SSD - The Brands That Matter
When evaluating SSDs in the consumer space, the buyer can get easily confused with the dizzying array of options. Rather than consolidating in the last year, the client SSD space continues to explode. Well, that's not entirely accurate, the number of manufacturers selling SSDs has increased, though the variation in solutions has not. To put a finer point on it, there are manufacturers who are innovating or otherwise adding value, and there are those who are simply slapping a brand on an SSD, without providing consumers with much of a support network or adding even incremental value along the way.
As the editorial team at StorageReview considers our content focus going forward, we think it's important to narrow our coverage to the key brands that consumers should be evaluating when buying an SSD. As a service to those purchasing an SSD for personal use, StorageReview is launching what amounts to a "Who's Who" in the SSD space to help consumers sort through the clutter. The brand buying guide will be updated regularly with manufacturer updates like new product releases or other major events occur to affect brand quality in the SSD space.
When evaluating consumer SSD companies, we're looking at four key factors: controller technology, NAND fab ownership, engineering prowess and brand power.
Controller Technology - We place extra emphasis on brands who own the SSD controllers they use. The benefits of using an in-house controller are massive from both a drive performance and reliability perspective, to drive support should an issue arise that needs to be addressed with a firmware revision.
NAND Fab Ownership - Much like the controller technology, an in-depth understanding of the NAND and being able to configure the NAND for specific SSD duty offers big advantages. Those who own their own NAND fabs also generally have pick of the litter when it comes to selecting the best of the best NAND for their own drives.
Engineering - A bit more difficult to define, but when evaluating engineering skills, we look at not only the total engineering staff for a manufacturer, but also interesting or unique software or firmware features an SSD possesses.
Brand Power - This catch all category generally applies to manufacturers who have a large presence in the US in terms of SSD sales and support, but are generally ordering parts and outsourcing assembly, rather than creating products on their own. Many of the former and current memory companies fit into this category as they look for ways to expand their business.
SSD Brands that Matter (in alphabetical order)
Corsair - Corsair has high brand awareness in the US consumer market, with products available at many US local and online retailers. Corsair also offers strong support channels, including telephone and online forum outreach. They also offer a wide range of top-performing controller options in their SSD families, including models that are based on the LAMD, SandForce and Marvell chipsets.
Crucial (Micron) - While their current generation SSDs might not tip the scales from a performance perspective, Micron has earned credit for offering reliable products and rapid response when there's an issue. They of course also own their own NAND fabs and have extensive in-house engineering teams and a brand that's well respected.
Intel - Intel is quick to point out at that they do more qualification work on their SSDs than anyone else. They were late to switch to SandForce controllers for this reason - the platform needed more stability before the Intel name went on SandForce based SSDs. Intel retains a NAND fab advantage even though they sold most of their NAND production interest back to Micron, and they of course offer engineering expertise via consumer and enterprise SSD controller technologies and offer a trusted brand name.
Kingston - While not always the first to market, Kingston takes a more measured approach that generally nets good results. Kingston offers an extensive client-focused SSD line that offers both performance and value models. Their SSDs are offered with an upgrade kit to easily transfer data from existing storage to a new SSD using Acronis cloning software and an external USB enclosure. Kingston has a long-standing support framework in place and while they don't have in-house engineering on the consumer SSDs, they do have an investment in JMicron flash controllers.
OCZ - OCZ owns their own controller technology and currently offers a full line of products based around their Barefoot contollers. They also are now owned by Toshiba, which gives them direct access to NAND, solving previous supply issues.
Samsung - Samsung is unique in the consumer SSD space in that they make every part inside the SSD, including controller, NAND, and SDRAM. With all components made in-house, Samsung can engineer products with strong integration from the hardware to software level. Going beyond performance advantages, this allows Samsung to quickly respond to firmware bugs and fully understand component failures at any level of the SSD.
SanDisk (WD) - Another late entry to the SandForce controller space, SanDisk pairs their own NAND and storage engineering expertise with SandForce to deliver one of the leading enthusiast SSDs in the SanDisk Extreme. SanDisk has been making flash-based storage for ages and certainly is a trusted and available brand in retail.
Seagate - A recent entry into the SSD space, at least on the consumer side, Seagate is taking the SSD market seriously, offering a complete portfolio based on the LAMD controller. It remains to be seen how diverse the roadmap will get and where Seagate goes long-term for NAND and controllers, but if nothing else it's a safe bet that Seagate will be there to stand behind the warranty.
What if an SSD brand isn't on this list?
If we don't list a brand as one that matters it could be because of several reasons. This is a US-centric list, so if a brand isn't generally available through major retailers in the US, it's probably not on our list. We also consider access to support, which again focuses on those with a large US footprint. Lastly, if we haven't seen an extensive number of a manufacturer's drives in our lab for testing, we can't vouch for the overall quality of the brand.
If a company isn't listed, we don't think their drives are worth buying at this time, outside of certain niche situations. StorageReview will only be providing editorial coverage for the brands on this list on a go forward basis. That said, the "Top SSD Brands That Matter" list will be updated as the industry evolves. Of course this is just a starting point; not all SSDs from even our Top 10 are worthy investments. For more detailed conversation and recommendations, use the StorageReview "What Drive Should I Buy?" forum.
Update 3/1/13 - Nearly a year after first published, we have pruned the list from ten brands that matter to nine, as Patriot Memory has reduced their offering significantly enough to effectively remove them from the SSD business.
Update 6/2/13 - Seagate has been added to the list, increasing the total number of brands back to ten.
Update 1/31/14 - We have ceased coverage of Plextor on the site. Their lack of direct access to NAND makes their drives more expensive and with a very small US footprint for sales and support, we no longer see them as a viable brand in this market.
Update 5/13/14 - OWC has been removed from our coverage list as they haven't shown much interest in the mainstream SSD space in the last year, though they do still have a few niche products that are compelling in certain markets.