Reviews Leaderboard Database Reference Search StorageReview Check Storage Prices Discussion FAQs Reliability Survey Search About StorageReview.com Contents

 

Reprinted, with permission, from
The PC Guide


Volume Compression Products

 Reference Guide - Hard Disk Drives 

Author: Charles M. Kozierok 

There are two main products on the market that are popularly used for volume compression in DOS and Windows. The first is DriveSpace (formerly called DoubleSpace), which is a Microsoft product that comes in various versions and with various versions of DOS and Windows. The second is Stacker, which is a product of Stac Electronics. I don't plan to get into a lengthy review of the two products because that is not the purpose of this part of the site. Both do a good job of providing compressed volumes, and each has some advantages and disadvantages.

I personally prefer the use of Microsoft's DriveSpace 3 product, for Windows 95, or the older DriveSpace 2 product for MS-DOS 6.22 (which is what you use if you are running Windows 3.x). This is not to disparage Stacker; in fact I have read that Stacker is a very good product and in many ways better than DriveSpace. I just feel more comfortable with DriveSpace because I have used it more, and because due to the dangers of using compression, I prefer having the compression software and operating system vendor be the same. I know that I will always be able to rely on the compression being supported fully by the operating system since they are made and tested by the same company (well, that's the theory anyway.)

It should be noted that the older DriveSpace 2 product is limited in its functionality compared to DriveSpace 3 and the latest version of Stacker. It only supports compressed volumes up to 512 MB, and that's the compressed volume size. If you want to compress a 1 GB host drive you have to split it into three or four compressed volumes. It also offers far fewer options to let you tailor how the compression is managed on the drive, and suffers from lower performance as well. DriveSpace 3 is a far superior product, but is supported only for Windows 95.

Note: DriveSpace 3 is not supported for use on FAT32 disk volumes.

Next: Free Space and the Estimated and Actual Compression Ratios

Return to the top of this page
© Copyright 1997-2005 Charles M. Kozierok. All Rights Reserved.
Write: Webmaster